Home
Themes
About
Blog
Vote of the Exiles
ImageAn analysis of the January 2005 Out-of-Country vote reveals the great faultline of post-Saddam Iraq: the desire of the Kurds for independence. So says Ali Tawfik-Shukor (25, Canada), a half-Shia, half Sunni Kurd Polling Officer in Toronto.

By Ali Tawfik-Shukor
Edited and published by Thinking-East.Net
Our copyright policy
To the forum discussion
Date published: 27/03/05
Section: Themes / Middle East
1,502 words 
Download article's PDF

Like millions of other Iraqis, my family left Iraq when I was only an infant. I have no recollection of what Iraq looks like, but I have always had the burning desire to learn more about my roots and the country I originated from. Therefore, I jumped at the opportunity to partake in the historic January 2005 Iraqi election as a Polling Officer with the International Organization for Migration (IOM) to coordinate the Iraqi-Out-of-Country Vote in Toronto, Canada.

Coming from a mixed background, with a mother who is Shia and father who is Sunni Kurd, I entered the elections with a utopian view of an Iraq that respects all races, cultures and religions. I never once sensed any sort of genuine tension between my parents or their families, and therefore always discredited those speaking of the divide between Iraq's various ethnic groups (Kurd, Sunni Arabs, Shia Arabs, Assyrians, Chaldeans, and Turkomans to name a few). Having grown up as a Canadian in Toronto, a very multicultural city, I was in for the reality-check of a lifetime when I was exposed to the real cultural divide between the various ethnicities that make up modern day Iraq. This divide was mirrored in the results of the Iraqi Out-of-Country Vote, which has been extremely poorly analyzed by the academic and political community.

The vote

265,148 expatriate Iraqis from fourteen different countries hosting the IOM's Out-of-Country Voting Program cast their ballot to vote for the political party of their choice. It was heartening to see thousands come to register and vote in the station I was working at, some who had to drive hundreds of kilometers in Canadian winter storm conditions. Many Iraqis came to register and vote by the busload, carrying their children and even their elderly. Many Iraqis cried when casting their vote, a lot of them saying that they felt like real Iraqis for the first time in their lives. One elderly lady cried out "Iraq is for the Iraqis… not for the Palestinians, Egyptians and other Arabs", referring to the fact that Saddam had always favored his Sunni Arab neighbours over the Iraq people during his reign of terror. One Shia gentleman lifted his baby's ink-stained finger up in the air saying "Zarqawi you criminal, this child challenges you", referring to Jordanian terrorist Abu Musab Al-Zarqawi who has killed hundreds of Iraqi civilians in an effort to create strife between the various Iraqi ethnic groups and factions.

Three main key points united the Iraqis who came out to vote: the intense hatred of Saddam's old Ba'ath regime, the desire of each ethnic group to be recognized, and the hope for a peaceful and prosperous future.

However, the real story lies in the results of the election, and what the results really mean. The Out-of-Country voting results for Iraqis abroad were: Shia 36.15%, Kurds 29.60%, and the list of candidates associated with interim Prime Minister Ayad Allawi trailing with 9.15% of the vote. A breakdown of the vote according to country is shown in the table below, which is a good indicator of the ethnic makeup of Iraqis within those countries1:

Iraqi Out-of-Country Voting Results (%)

 

Kurd

Shia

Allawi

Total

29.6

36.15

9.15

UAE

3

48.06

25.3

Australia

9.43

29.6

3.5

Canada

15.79

29.87

5.49

Germany

69.64

13.46

2.8

Denmark

28.54

42.73

5.6

France

42.93

15.89

6.71

Iran

12.19

69.29

4.92

Jordan

1.64

44.55

30.79

Netherlands

59.45

20.98

3.84

Sweden

54.71

19.12

4.23

Syria

1.63

31.07

34.81

Turkey

1.46

1.02

1.81

US

61.69

19.14

5.23

UK

16.94

31.66

4.23


The results of the Out-of-Country vote roughly paralleled the in-country vote, where of about 8.56 million votes cast in the election, the Shias received 4.08 million votes (48%), the Kurds garnered 2.17 million (25%), and the list of interim Prime Minister Ayad Allawi got 1.17 million (14%)2.  The reason the Kurds had a significantly higher Out-of-Country vote was due to the relatively higher importance of the election to them in their quest for self-determination; therefore, many Kurds took extra initiative to go the extra mile and vote wherever they could.

This was reflected in Nashville, Tennessee (USA) which has about 8,000 Kurds. More than 95% of the 3,930 Iraqi expatriates who registered there cast ballots, despite extreme winter storm conditions. The 95.3% turnout rate, or 3,744 people, was the highest out of five U.S. cities that held voting Friday through Sunday and ranked 13th out of 36 cities worldwide that allowed out-of-country voting3.  This incredibly high Kurdish turnout mirrored the turnout across the three provinces of Iraqi Kurdistan - Sulaimaniya, Erbil and Dohuk - which averaged 84%, well above the national average of 58%. Dohuk had the highest voter turnout in all of Iraq, where a whopping 89% of eligible voters came out to cast their ballot.

Meaning of the vote

What do these results mean, and why did a disproportionately high percentage of Kurds come out to vote? This became very clear through my observations while working as a polling officer in Toronto. The Kurds did not come to vote for Iraq - they came to vote for Kurdistan. This should not be surprising to anyone who is aware of the upcoming 17th anniversary of Hussein's brutal chemical attacks on the Kurdish village of Halabja in March of 1988. Under Iraq's regimes, the Kurds have been subjected to 80 years of repression, enslavement and genocide4.  Over 200,000 Kurdish villagers perished in Saddam's ethnic cleansing campaign, many of whom are only now being dug out of mass graves. After decades of seeing nothing but death and destruction from Iraq, it is only natural for the Kurds to choose liberation and self-determination.

Apart from repression, the Kurds also share very little with the rest of Iraq. They are a completely different race of Indo-European origin; they speak their own distinct Kurdish language; and they are secular, as compared to the religious Islamic Shia and Sunni Arabs of Iraq. In fact, after over a decade of relative isolation from the rest of Iraq, a whole new generation of Kurds have emerged that speak no Arabic whatsoever in semi-autonomous Iraqi Kurdistan. Over this short period of time, the Kurds have prospered, as compared to the rest of Iraq that has been nearly completely destroyed by Saddam and his cronies. The Kurds want nothing to do with the rest of Iraq, which is currently mired by suicide bombers, religious fanaticism, and economic stagnation.

Referendum movement

In 2003, Kurdish activists collected 1.7 million signatures on a petition demanding a referendum on the future of northern Iraq's Kurdish region. Parallel to the 2005 Iraqi vote, nearly two million (1,998,061) people participated in a referendum voting for Kurdish independence. 98.8% (1,973,412 people) voted for independence, and only 20,251 voted for staying inside Iraq. The choice of independence was a constant pattern in every part of Kurdistan including areas outside the Kurdish administration, such as the hotly contested areas of Khanaqin and Kirkuk. In Kirkuk province, 131,582 people participated in the referendum, 131,274 people voted for independence and only 181 people voted for staying inside Iraq5.  The referendum document is collecting dust on a table at the United Nations.

What's next?

I walked into the elections as a naïve Iraqi who believed that the elections symbolized hope for all the ethnic groups within the context of a united Iraq. I walked out as a more mature, culturally-aware and pragmatic Iraqi. I realize that the Kurds have finally had enough tyranny, enough genocide, and enough racism and destruction at the hands of the Iraqi state for the past 80 years. They came out in masses, carrying Kurdish flags, wearing Kurdish clothes, refusing to speak anything but Kurdish when entering the polling station. This enraged the other Iraqi polling officers, who threatened to walk off the job unless the Kurds removed their flags and anything else that showed their ethnic identity. I was shocked to see other Iraqi pollsters call security to remove an elderly Kurdish woman who had a t-shirt on that simply said, "I love Kurdistan". When a Kurd spoke Kurdish, he or she was always told to speak Arabic, despite the fact that many didn't know how to.

For the first time in my life, I saw how very real this "Kurdophobia" really is, and realized how impossible it was for Kurds and Arabs to coexist within the context of an unified Iraqi state - a state formed by colonial powers with artificial boundaries that divided 40 million oppressed Kurds between Turkey, Syria, Iraq and Iran. In little over a decade, the Kurds have shown the entire world that they can take care of their own affairs. Their progressive and forward-thinking democratic institutions can serve as a beacon of hope and a model of prosperity for the entire region. The latest vote in Iraq revealed the aspirations of a people that have been brutalized for too long. If self-determination truly is a globally accepted principle, it is time to let the Kurdish people go.



Endnotes

Ali Tawfik-Shukor (shukor at gmail.com) is the Director of the Iraqi Kurdistan Health Policy Development Project, and a member of the Kurdish Scientific and Medical Association (KSMA) and the Iraqi Society for Higher Education.  The first edition of this article was published March 18th in the Kurdish Regional Government website.

1) www.iraqocv.org
2) http://www.ieciraq.org/English/
3) www.thedailytimes.com/sited/story/html/184855
4) http://www.cbc.ca/fifth/kurds
5) http://www.kurdistanreferendum.org/

 

Comments
Some links
Written by Brooklyn on 2006-12-28 13:22:46

Links for you: order cheap amoxicillin online is page about order cheap amoxicillin online. valium online cheap is page about valium online cheap. adderall online pharmacy is page about adderall online pharmacy. ambien cr side effects is page about ambien cr side effects. azithromycin is page about azithromycin. clomid substitute is page about clomid substitute. nexium side effects is page about nexium side effects. cheap viagra is page about cheap viagra. zoloft rebate is page about zoloft rebate. cheap soma no prescription is page about cheap soma no prescription. generic soma is page about generic soma. order ultram is page about order ultram. tylenol pm is page about tylenol pm. over the counter tramadol is page about over the counter tramadol. wellbutrin xl side effects is page about wellbutrin xl side effects. online prescription vicodin is page about online prescription vicodin. cheapest tramadol is page about cheapest tramadol. cheapest amoxicillin is page about cheapest amoxicillin. wellbutrin sale is page about wellbutrin sale.
Jalal Talabani
Written by C Schwartz on 2005-04-11 14:28:07

Kurdish leader Jalal Talabani has been named Iraqi president.  
 
A profile of Mr. Talabani can be found at the BBC: http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/middle_east/4421261.stm

Write Comment
Name:
Title:
BBCode:Web AddressEmail AddressBold TextItalic TextUnderlined TextQuoteCodeOpen ListList ItemClose List
Comment:

Code:*
*A wrong code will delete the comment.
Code

Powered by AkoComment 2.0!


Back issues